It's a good scenario, but it has the downside of very little replayability despite it changing the murderer.
Watching one of our players get skull-drug around the map by the mob made for a good time once we knew we were screwed. I feel as if a second play through now that I'm experienced with the game would be much easier but man was that first game both hilariously fun and damningly hard. We were so close to the end but did a few things out of order that hurt us.
It is probably my favorite as far as actually making me feel way in over my head. Escape from Innsmouth: Second scenario ever played, first scenario ever failed.Cycle of Eternity: Very solid as a tutorial level, can be fun if you're just looking for a quick game and have added new expansions as that will alternate some of the room tiles/monsters you face but is the quickest scenario to get bored with (but again, its job is to be a tutorial).I've played it twice and have found it miserable both times I just feel as if it punishes you more than any other scenario for not playing it perfectly, yet it does a lot of things to slow you down and throw you off base. The only one I would actually say I strongly dislike is Astral Alchemy.